I’ve “vibe coded” two web applications now, and I don’t think I like it very much.
Both of the new apps work, kinda — at least, they pretty much do what I want them to, give or take some fine-tuning and a UI polish — but on both occasions I only managed to make it as far as that MVP stage before putting the idea down … and never feeling any desire to go back to it. Right now, I have no motivation to pursue either one of the projects any further, despite one of them being something I’ve been thinking about building for a decade.
My “vibe” process followed roughly the same trajectory for both apps:
- Describe the basic idea to ChatGPT (on a normal free account) then answer its refinement questions until it was able to spit out a functional spec;
- Feed the functional spec to an AI-powered IDE (the free trial of Claude in Windsurf on the first occasion; Codex with an OpenAI API key in VS Code on the second) to generate a working prototype;
- Play with, debug and enhance the prototype (through text-only input) until it roughly matched what I originally envisaged.
So, as a concept/process, vibe coding works. Both times the AI produced a working prototype, with an ugly but functional UI, and a backend that handled everything I wanted plus probably incorporated more security and best practices than I would have written myself on a first attempt. On the first occasion, it also generated a two-part Docker setup (because I asked it to) but then refactored it into a single deployment when I challenged its initial architectural decision.
There’s only one problem with writing code this way, though.
It gets rid of everything that is fun about writing code.
The only thing these exercises made me realise is that I love the actual process of writing code. Choosing the right HTML elements and writing the right CSS to make a layout work; deciding how to architect a function or a class or an API; spending time debugging a broken page until you isolate the line that has been causing all the problems and come up with an elegant solution. Those are the things that got me into coding in the first place.
I don’t want to bypass all of that positive feeling and instead replace it with a fragmented couple of hours spent watching a chat window tell me that it’s “Thinking.”