House of Leaves definitely lives up to its reputation as a challenging read, and not just because it's ridiculously heavy. It's hard to land on a rating for the book; the central story is compelling and well-told, but then is surrounded by so much self-aware discursive time-wasting that you often find yourself flicking forward looking for any kind of point that it might actually arrive at. The typography (and the size of the pages) makes it harder to read than it needs to be, and the frequently explicit footnotes don't really seem to serve any narrative purpose. And then it ends, abruptly, albeit with almost 200 pages of appendices still to get through. Overall, I'm glad I read it, but I'll never pick it up again.
Speeches that have been turned into essays aren't the easiest things to read, especially when the written version neglects to add any paragraph breaks. But that's the only fault you can find with this book, as the arguments that it makes are just as relevant almost 100 years later.
On the shorter side for a book - it reads more like a long-form New Yorker article - and it's lacking a coherent through-line to tie Conroy's reminiscences about Nantucket from the 1950s up until the early 2000s. Twenty years after his death, you wonder what he would make of the place now, with Presidents past and present among the regular summer visitors.