Writing
A blog of acquiescent temper, miscellaneous opinions, and uncertain vote.

The Three Musketeers: D'Artagnan (2023)

There is always the faintest stumbling block when sitting down to watch a foreign language film. For the first couple of minutes, as your brain struggles to get used to the detachment of the acting from the words being spoken, it somehow feels as if the actors aren’t doing a good enough job – you’re forced to read something extra simply to understand what is going on. Of course, the feeling inevitably soon passes, especially when the film is as good as The Three Musketeers: D'Artagnan proves to be.

Alexandre Dumas’s timeless tale of a young man swept along by the tide of religious and political intrigue has been adapted for the screen many times in the past; from Douglas Fairbanks buckling swashes in the 1920s, through peak 1990s casting of Young Guns’ Charlie Sheen and Kiefer Sutherland, on up to the most recent pseudo-steampunk re-imagining in 2011 by Resident Evil helmer Paul W.S. Anderson. The most well-known version is probably the 1973 film that starred Oliver Reed, Richard Chamberlain and Michael York which, like this new French release, made the sensible decision to split the lengthy book into two separate films.

The plot of this first movie, while broadly hewing to that of the 1844 novel, does take a few liberties with the source material. Young D'Artagnan (François Civil) travels to Paris with hopes of joining the famous Musketeers, accidentally picks a fight with three of its most celebrated members, impresses them with his swordplay and joins them in a race to retrieve the Queen’s jewels and save their friend from the gallows. In the background, the political machinations of Catholics and Protestants, cardinals and kings drive the plot forward without getting bogged down in the details that make the novel hard going at times. Some of the stakes are raised – a murder leads to one of the titular three being framed, resulting in a race against time to prove his innocence – while some are lowered; Constance is now young and unmarried, leaving room for romance with D'Artagnan. Loyal servant Planchet is also, sadly, missing from this telling of the story.

The direction by Martin Bourboulon is universally excellent; the chemistry between the main cast (including Vincent Cassel as Athos, Pio Marmaï as Porthos, Romain Duris as Aramis, and Lyna Khoudri as Constance) sparkles, and the action scenes, although few and far between, ratchet up the pace to near martial arts levels: the initial fight scene wherein the four leads take on the Cardinal’s men is cut and blocked almost like a scene from 2011’s The Raid; the score is silent, leaving only the grunts and shouts of the cast (who trained for six months by an Olympic swordsman) as they whirl and parry around and over the always-moving camera. The sets, too, are exquisite – the film was shot mainly on location all over France – and the lighting at times recalls the famous candlelit scenes in Kubrick’s Barry Lyndon (1975).

Eva Green’s Milady is unfortunately a little one-note, having not much more to do apart from look sly and self-satisfied whenever she’s on screen, but Phantom Thread’s Vicky Krieps makes the most of her limited screen time as the two-timing Queen Anne at the centre of the film’s two-hour runtime.

Overall, it’s easily one of the best interpretations of the beloved novel (not counting the near-perfect Dogtanian and the Three Muskehounds, of course); it remains to be seen whether the second part, The Three Musketeers: Milady, set to be released in December 2023, can stick the landing.

9/10