Coming off the back of several underwhelming albums (you need to go all the way back to 2010’s Together to find traces of the brilliance that infused their first three releases), expectations weren’t exactly high for Continue as a Guest, The New Pornographers’ first in four years. But it turns out that the restrictions placed on the band by COVID (only rarely able to record together, bandleader AC Newman wrote, recorded, produced and mixed the album alone as contributions from the five other members arrived from their own lockdown locations) might have been just what The New Pornographers needed to recapture some of the magic that elevates them to more than just another Newman side-project.
Although the continued absence of Destroyer’s Dan Bejar from the TNP line-up is still felt in the lack of any of his distinctly structured songs or laconic vocal delivery (he has a single credit here, on opener Really Really Light, thanks to a recovered guitar hook from the 2014 Brill Bruisers sessions), Newman’s typically abstruse lyrics pair well with the droning, driving songwriting he delivers on this album; he eschews any attempt to match phrasing to melody, splitting words across bars with wild abandon and turning any attempt to puzzle out the lyrics (beautifully delivered as usual by Neko Case and/or Kathryn Calder) into an exercise in frustration.
Ultimately, despite the lack of any standout tracks to match the quality of Sing Me Spanish Techno or Letter From An Occupant, there’s still a lot to like here, and the marked improvement over their last few releases bodes well for a future where The New Pornographers are once again able to reconvene in a post-COVID studio, together.