Writing
A blog of acquiescent temper, miscellaneous opinions, and uncertain vote.

Cecil B Demented (2000)

One has to wonder how many Hollywood A-listers would include the name of John Waters on their personal list of “Directors I’d really like to work with”. Melanie Griffith, perhaps aggrieved at receiving seven Razzie nominations in the last ten years (after an Oscar nom in 1988 for Working Girl), was at least one such, when she signed up to star in this bizarrely off-the-rails satire.

It had been more than a decade since Waters experienced a genuine success (Hairspray in 1988; his more recent movies Cry-Baby (1990), Serial Mom (1994) and Pecker (1998) had all flopped at the box office) but it seems that his reputation was still sufficient to attract a motley combination of future film and TV stars (a pre-stardom Michael Shannon and Maggie Gyllenhaal, as well as Alicia Witt, Adrian Grenier and The Wire’s Larry Gilliard, Jr.) together with a handful of Waters’ alumni (Mink Stole and Ricki Lake) and they mostly seem to be having great fun alongside Stephen Dorff as the titular Cecil. Demented is a radical filmmaker determined to upset the status quo and force a rebirth of ‘true’ cinema (his followers have the names of notable–and, presumably, 'true’–directors tattooed onto their bodies, ranging from Preminger and Peckinpah to Spike Lee), which he attempts to accomplish through a lot of violence, yelling, and sexual abstinence on the part of his crew (this part is, sadly, never explained in any detail, and mostly seems to be an excuse for a bawdy sex scene towards the end of the movie).

Griffith, as the Hollywood diva kidnapped by the terrorist filmmaker and forced to star in his magnum opus, does well enough, although the subject matter does make it hard to tell whether she’s acting badly or badly acting. The staging and script are typical of Waters; high melodrama is the order of the day, although most of the cast do at least manage to deliver their ridiculous lines with a straight face. Patty Hearst, whose 1974 kidnapping and subsequent participation in her kidnapper’s crimes serve as a loose inspiration, even shows up late in the film as a concerned mother. And, although the individual pieces wouldn’t stand up to much scrutiny in any serious film, taken as a whole Cecil B. Demented is still a worthy addition to Waters’ oeuvre.

8/10