
Hanya Yanagihara’s 2015 second novel, A Little Life, was a revelation. Intricately plotted, with heart-breakingly real characters, even after 800-plus pages you didn’t want it to end.
So it’s therefore a huge disappointment to discover that her follow-up, 2022’s To Paradise, is such a shallow pastiche of what came before, replacing the richly drawn lives of the former book with boring, predictable, and to a large extent cliché snapshots of the lives of too many new characters to even care about keeping track of.
To Paradise is presented in three parts concerning tenuously related characters and locations, each separated by 100 years. In 1893 we follow David Bingham, the weak and ineffectual scion of a grand New York family, as he embarks on a love affair with an impoverished teacher, while his grandfather attempts to marry him off to a richer, older man. (The central conceit of this section of the book being an alternate history of the United States where New England is an independent country and homosexuality is legal. Unfortunately that aspect of society seems to be the full extent of Yanagihara’s limited imagination in that regard, leaving us with not so much representation as fetishisation; virtually every named character is gay.)
As Part One sputters to an inconclusive and unsatisfying end, Part Two picks up the story, introducing us to yet another David Bingham, living in the same New York mansion one hundred years later during the AIDS crisis. One might have expected Yanagihara to explicitly connect these characters who have so much in common, but unfortunately she decides that the naming conceit should simply be a way to confuse her audience and make the book just that little bit harder to follow.
The third and final part of the novel jumps forward by another 100 years, where in 2093 we find yet more Binghams, this time living through endless pandemics that have led to a near-fascist regime in the US, while other countries remain relatively unaffected politically. This section of the book can at least boast something approaching a plot, as a lowly lab tech pieces together clues about a new virus. Letters from the past are interspersed with the narrative, providing an insight into the breakdown of society that has happened over the years of repeated global pandemics. Interestingly, despite coming out in 2022, Yanagihara claims this part of the novel was written entirely before Covid; it’s unfortunate then that it feels so much like an exercise in bandwagon-jumping.
Overall, then, To Paradise is simultaneously beautifully written yet staggeringly dull, and the obsession with the lives of gay men makes it feel not unlike a particularly literary slashfic, albeit one where we don’t actually care all that much about the people involved.