Writing
A blog of acquiescent temper, miscellaneous opinions, and uncertain vote.

Detroit: Become Human

I didn’t play Detroit: Become Human when it was first released in May 2018 on PlayStation 4, or when the PC version came out a year and a half later. I came to the game late, via Steam’s 2025 Black Friday sale, and so for me it’s impossible to divorce the characters in the game from today’s pervasive and omnipresent AI.

Detroit: Become Human is a narrative adventure game in which the player follows the stories of (and controls) three androids as they break free from their programming, attain consciousness, and participate in (or, in one case, attempt to stop) an android emancipation-slash-revolution. The paths of these three androids — Kara, a home-help providing childcare services; Markus, a caretaker and assistant for an elderly, wheelchair-bound artist; and Connor, a new model of android designed to hunt down so-called ‘deviants’ — weave and intersect as the at-times emotional and affecting storylines play out, guided by the player’s actions and choices at key moments.

In fact, player choice is really the primary game mechanic in play here. While it may play much like any other third-person video game, with the current character controlled via the left thumbstick while freely looking around using the right, there is very little that relies on player skill, aim, or quick reflexes (other than a very small number of fight scenes where all that is required of the player is to press the right buttons quickly enough). The main gameplay loop, then, is simply looking at things, and choosing what to say (or not say) during conversations with the many different characters you meet during your journey(s). Apologise or remain silent and someone’s opinion of you will rise; choose to be aggressive or sarcastic and that same person is more likely to turn against you — although maybe not for several more chapters. Future options are unlocked by certain choices or discoveries, and the opinions or relationships you build (or destroy) will also have a potentially unforeseen effect later in the game.

As you progress further through the relatively short game (it can be finished in under ten hours), the three primary stories converge, intertwine … and sometimes end. The game’s writer and director, David Cage, has been famously critical of “game over” events, calling them “a failure of game design”; it is not difficult to bring the story of one or more of your android avatars to a premature end, leaving the remaining characters to push on towards their own endings. There are said to be more than a hundred possible endings to experience, depending on your choice of action (or inaction), and it’s truly impressive just how many of the branching narrative pathways the game’s writers allow you to explore. Don’t worry though, as it is always possible to return to a previous chapter and replay it, making different decisions and revealing new branches of the story.

While a few scenarios step over the line into cliché — the world-weary, alcoholic detective playing Russian roulette in his seedy apartment because he lost his only child is probably the most egregious example, but there’s also a sex-bot brothel — some story beats have real emotional weight. An early scene requiring the player to choose whether to refuse your owner’s order to remain downstairs or intervene before he beats his child, has you (as Kara) literally breaking through the mental walls of her programming in order to take action.

One annoyance in a game that is obviously intended to be played and replayed is that so much of the game is unskippable, at least on PC — individual dialogue lines and entire cut scenes cannot be skipped at all, which can be more than a little frustrating, especially on subsequent playthroughs — and the Pause menu is equally unresponsive during many segments.

Ultimately Detroit: Become Human is a prescient game that certainly hits differently when played today. Leaving aside the occasionally heavy-handed slavery/equal rights allegory, it’s interesting now to judge the behaviours and choices available to the android protagonists through the modern lens of AI. Some of the scripted responses available to players, particularly for the Connor character, have a real ring of generative AI conversation to them, despite being written five or more years prior to LLMs stepping onto the world stage.